|
Why Tall Men Have Prettier
Girlfriends:
What science tells us about height
and attraction, the ceiling effect, why 6 feet tall is the
benchmark and why you should date women shorter than you.
|
|
|
Christopher Philip |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
It's a fact of life. Height is just one of those things we can do
very little, if anything, about, and yet it is so very important in
dating and attraction. I will go through a variety of points to show
you exactly how important it is and what researchers have found
about the preferences women have when it comes to this quality. The
end result might bring tears, but there is no sense ignoring good
hard science. By acknowledging the reality of the situation, you can
use your approaches on women more selectively and sparingly, you can
employ lifts in your shoes or you can use one of those stretching
machines! Really, there isn't a whole lot that can be done to fix
inherent height issues, but by knowing about their existence, you
can modify your "game" and end up more successful in
dating. Acting according to what the science says is the best way to
work most efficiently. Without wasting any more time, let's get
straight into the research.
According to Hartfeil and Sprechler (1986) height is one of the
most important characteristics determining overall physical
attractiveness as determined by women. I doubt that any reasonable
person would refute this statement. However, at the same time, one
may not understand the extent of its importance. The male taller
norm is the cardinal rule of dating. Gillis and Avis (1980) took
information collected from bank account applications and found that
only 2 couples out of 720 consisted of a pair in which the woman was
taller than the man. This is an outstandingly large number. This
means that you have less than a one percent chance of courting and
marrying a woman who is taller than you. Having a small chance does
not mean no chance at all though. Being shorter simply means that
you are going to have to work harder to get a woman who is taller.
Tall women are looking for the same qualities as short women after
all. However, if she is taller than you, she will expect more in
terms of resources and power to make up for the height difference.
In a study by Hensley (1994) women preferred a man who was 72
inches (183 cm) tall as a benchmark. The preference for the six foot
tall man is overwhelming, says Hensley. In his study, consisting of
145 females, 32 percent reported this as their preferred height.
Thirty-two percent is not everyone, and most certainly not the
majority, so this statistic might give you hope! The 68 percent of
women who don't prefer the 6 foot tall man are also potential
suitors, and must be considered. However, fundamentally there are
even fewer that are suitable for you because some of these women
might prefer men who are taller or even shorter than you regardless
of what height you happen to be, further shrinking your pool of
eligible women. Here comes the better news. In a study by Cameron
(1978) it was found that 100 percent of the women advertised the
desire to date a man who was 4 inches taller than themselves.
Hensley's (1994) study, mentioned above, showed that on average,
women and men both prefer the man to be 2 to 3 inches taller than
the woman in a relationship. Why is this news better? It's better
for the simple fact that it destroys the 6 foot tall benchmark rule.
That is, men aren't at a huge disadvantage just because they aren't
all 6 feet tall. Men simply must be taller then the women they seek.
It is much easier to change your target date than it is to change
your height! Furthermore, a study by Shepperd and Strathman (1989)
revealed that 95 percent of the female participants preferred a
taller man, 3 percent the same height and 2 percent preferred males
shorter than themselves. Therefore it suggests that it is not the
absolute height but rather the relative height that matters the
most. Finally, we have something to work from! If we accept this
information, and we should, than we also accept that you and I, and
everyone else, will have a far better chance of getting what we want
from a woman who is shorter than ourselves.

As you might expect, height has been shown to be more important
to men than to women's attractiveness. So why is it that women find
height to be so important? Beigel's (1954) study showed that people
attribute everything from dominance, superiority, fearlessness,
protectiveness, ambitiousness, leadership qualities, athleticism and
sheer physical strength to tall people over shorter people. Tall men
also tended to command attention from others, which women found
appealing.
If all this wasn't enough, tall men also get other societal
fringe benefits. Not only is height important in dating, it has also
been shown that taller men (about 6 feet 2 inches and over) have
higher starting salaries. They are also more likely to be hired in
the first place, particularly by sales recruiters. They are more
often selected as leaders and chosen for corporate training
programs.
So if you are short what can you do about it? Not a hell of a
lot, that's for sure! You must at least accept that these rules
apply. All the bitching in the world will never change this. Just
accept it, and then deal with it. If you are short, get rich and
powerful, then nothing else matters! If you are tall, enjoy the
perks - at least until you get to the next paragraph where I will
discuss the ceiling effect. There is one other bit of information
that may be of assistance. It is taken from Wilson (1968) in Lerner
and Moore (1974) who showed that height estimates were related to
academic status. That is, as the man's academic status increased, he
was also judged to be taller. This means that if you make yourself
out to be smarter or as having a more prestigious occupation, then
you are more likely to be thought of as taller. Therefore, it is
possible to boost your status to boost your perceived height, be it
only temporarily. At the end of the night when you are standing face
to face (or face to breast!) she will surely note your exact height
regardless of your occupation.
Interestingly, there seems to be a "ceiling effect"
where tall males (over 6 feet) suffer a decrease in fitness. That
is, women tend to find extremely tall men less attractive. This has
been noted by several researchers. Women tend to prefer men of a
medium stature over really tall men or really short men. In a study
by Graziano et. al. (1978) similar results showed that men of medium
height (5'9"- 5'11") were rated as more attractive over
shorter (5'5"- 5'7") or taller men (6'2"- 6'4"),
regardless of the height of the women (4'10"- 6'1"). This
means that if you aren't average, or slightly above average, then
you are going to have to work hard to attract mates.

No question, as the research shows, height is important in the
dating marketplace. Men are dated more frequently when they are
taller, have a social advantage over shorter men, and even have been
shown to have prettier girlfriends. Therefore, searching for a mate
is more difficult if you are short. However, if you are shorter,
look on the bright side – women report dating men more frequently
who are taller than themselves but do not necessarily rate them as
better looking. I'm sure that really matters, right?
References
Beigel H.G. 1954. Body height in mate selection. Journal of
Social Psychology 39: 257-268.
Bercheid E. and E. Walster. 1974. Physical attractiveness. L.
Berkowitz, ed. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. Academic
Press, New York.
Cameron C., S. Oskamp and W. Sparks. 1978. Courtship American
style: newspaper advertisements. Family Coordinator 26: 27-30.
Feingold A. 1982. Do taller men have prettier girlfriends?
Psychological Reports 50: 810.
Gillis J.S. and W.E. Avis. 1980. The male-taller norm in mate
selection. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 6: 396-401.
Graziano W., T. Brothen and E. Berscheid. 1978. Height and
attraction: Do men and women see eye-to-eye? Journal of Personality
46: 128-145.
Hartfeil E. and S. Sprechler. 1986. Mirror, Mirror…The
Importance of Looks in Everyday Life. State University of New York
Press, Albany.
Hensley W.E. 1994. Height as a basis for interpersonal
attraction. Adolescence 29: 469-474.
Kurtz, D.L. 1969. Physical appearance and stature: important
variables in sales recruiting Personnel Journal December: 981-983.
Pawlowski B., R.I.M. Dunbar, and A. Lipowicz. 2000. Tall men have
more reproductive success. Nature 403: 184.
Pierce C.A. 1996. Body height and romantic attraction: a
meta-analytic test of the male-taller norm. Social Behavior and
Personality 24: 143-150.
Shepperd J.A. and A.J. Strathman. 1989. Attractiveness and
height: the role of stature in dating preference, frequency of
dating, and perceptions of attractiveness.
Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 15: 617-627.
Stogdill R. 1948. Personal factors associated with leadership.
Journal of Psychology 25:35-71.
Wilson P.R. 1968. Perceptual distortion of height as a function
of ascribed academic status. Journal of Social Psychology 74:
97-107.
Woll S. 1986. So many to choose from: decision strategies in
videodating. Journal of Social and Personality Relationships 3:
43-52. |